Findingmeg's Comments

Fished up "Mr. Pinchy" (not the Magical Crawdad Box), who provided three wishes (charges), each followed by a 4 hour cooldown.  You have to be Level 55 to "use" a charge.  Fished him up by fishing the Highland Mixed Schools in Blackwind Lake in Terokkar Forest exclusively, where you go to do the Skettis dailies.  It took a total of 193 successful casts.

I'm Alliance, and this was in our AH for 4,850G. Another person had it up bid only for 50G. I bid on it, was outbid within the next 24 hours at some point, but thanks to the ability to check the AH remotely these days, I was able to re-bid from work (thank you, Blizzard!) and monitor it until I was alerted to the win. I am feeling SUPER lucky right now! :D

Found another one 10 minutes later just NW of there at Lake Kel'Theril.  Don't know of rarity b/c I left it for next person.  Luck to all  :)